“Critical thinking” are trigger words to some people. Teaching critical thinking is even illegal in public schools in parts of America. A kneejerk reaction to new ideas or something one dislikes is critical but non-thinking.
Merriam Webster Dictionary defines critical thinking as, “The act or practice of thinking critically (as by applying reason and questioning assumptions) in order to solve problems, evaluate information, discern biases, etc.” To this I would add applying evidence.
Scientists have used critical thinking to dispel false beliefs such as bloodletting to cure disease. Critical thinking has enabled Christians to dispel poor interpretations of the Bible such as indulgencies and witch burning.
“Give me a current example,” you might ask. Okay. I recently read a non-fiction book, Sapiens, by Yuval Noah Harari. It had remained on The New York Times best-seller list for 182 weeks. Mr. Harari’s premise is that mankind became dominant on earth through cooperation. Although politically divided, we definitely cooperate using specialized skills. Sapiens is also a pessimistic book predicting the pending doom of mankind while offering no solutions.
Mr. Harari reveals his own bias with an idealized view of ancient hunter-gathers. He asserts, “Ancient forgers were the most knowledgeable and skillful people in history.” (paperback pg 49) Admittedly ancient forgers had skills to kill mammoths with spears that I don’t. He calls mankind’s development of agriculture “a trap” (pg 87) although it enabled the development of diverse skills and population growth. Most modern humans spend 12 to 20 years in schools deliberately acquiring knowledge and skills. The average life expectancy of primitive people was about twenty-four years. How could they be the pinnacle of human development? Maybe Mr. Harari hopes civilization will collapse allowing a remnant to become hunter-gathers.
Critical thinking tells me that Mr. Harari has passed wishful baloney to a lot of people.
Drew